top of page

New markets, one at a time

Updated: Nov. 11. 2018

“If he sends reinforcements everywhere, he will everywhere be weak.”
Sun Zi, The Art of War.

I was sitting on the advisory committee of an innovative company with a product of worldwide potential. The company had just launched its product in two American regions, as well as two countries in Europe where it had won two prestigious awards. The founder allocated a major part of his time and resources to its international expansion. The problem was that the company had not yet started to generate a profit in Quebec, their original market, and was facing competitors who copied their products, were profitable and focussed on the Quebec market. Despite our warnings, the founder persisted in his efforts to go international and neglected many weaknesses in Quebec. A few years later, the company filed for protection under the Bankruptcy Act.

 

How does a local business go about becoming national? And how do you break into foreign markets?

 

In the initial phase of expansion, the answer is always, one region at a time. For the first foreign markets, the answer is one country at a time. Even for a continental market such as the United States or China, the answer is one region at a time. As a prerequisite, the company must have consolidated its position in the original market and already made money there.

 

Many companies lost ground when tackling several markets simultaneously. Even major businesses can bite the dust. Remember Target’s nightmare, going outside the United States for the first time by simultaneously opening 133 stores in 9 Canadian provinces. Despite their considerable means, Target Canada put themselves under bankruptcy protection in January 2015, less than 2 years after the initial opening. 

In order to be successful in every new major market, the company must go through not only a difficult learning curve, but also, and it can be surprising, through a complete transformation of the way it operates.

 

To break into a new market, you must understand the local customers’ and consumers’ preferences, be familiar with the networks of influence, break in an operational infrastructure, establish your credibility as a reliable supplier, and position yourself against the already established competition.

 

But there is more, and it’s what most growing companies forget to take into account. The entrepreneur or president must assimilate new management practices. He can no longer ‘manage to view’.

 

He must learn to be efficient at a higher delegating level, which means hiring top managers, sharing his vision with them, implementing new performance assessment systems and trusting. The organizational structure must be reviewed and ensure that adequate resources are in place to support an expanding business, i.e. in customer service, operations and finance departments. In some cases, a new financial system is needed to handle multi-site operations. That’s a tall order.  

 

When I started with Van Houtte, we had initially tried to launch our grocery products in Ontario and in 3 American regions simultaneously. The results were disappointing. We then tried a different approach, one that was focussed and in stages. We targeted the Atlantic Provinces first, a small, less competitive market where we could learn to manage remotely at low risk. Within 6 months, we had taken over 50% of the Arabica coffee market in supermarkets, and had set up a small local team. The following 6 months our development efforts were directed almost exclusively to the western provinces’ market, where we quickly gained a major market share and set up a team there.

OLD VH PACKS.jpg

Van Houtte packaging launched in the 1990’s to tap into new markets outside Québec.

Only the following year did we target Ontario, the most difficult market in the country. The experience gained in the two previous regions, more significant resources on which we could rely, and the credibility we had established in the rest of the country allowed us to quickly acquire some major clients, such as Loblaw. At the end of this second year, our market share outside Quebec had reached 85% for arabica coffee.

But to achieve that, we had to simultaneously increase our production capacity, create new packaging, build up a new customer service team, set up a marketing department, develop a reliable logistics chain for each new market (usually with new transporters) and review the way we recruited, trained and managed our regional managers.

We seem to forget that even companies that dominate their market at a global level achieved success through a similar process. Starbucks was founded in 1971 and remained a chain in Northwest United States until its acquisition by Howard Schultz in 1987. The company opened its first café in Chicago at the end of 1987 and, for three years, all development efforts were limited to the Midwest.

The company expanded in California in 1991. Only after succeeding to solidly establish itself, Starbucks opened their first shops on the east coast, first in Washington in 1993 and then New York in 1994. “Our strategy was to gain a foothold in each market and create a strong presence before we moved to another city,” wrote Howard Schultz in Pour Your Heart Into It. The book describes the organizational changes that were needed to go from one step to the next.

 

Companies such as Budweiser, General Mills and General Foods went through similar stages of growth during the first decades of their history.

starbucks.jpg

Only after succeeding in two or three major markets and having sufficient capital on hand can a company take on more than one new market at a time. In any case, never open more than a few markets at a time…

 

How do we define the borders of the new regional market to tackle? Chicago, or all the Midwest states? Northeastern United States, or New England except for the New York region? A market is a region first and foremost with distinct networks for retail and distribution, distinct influence networks, a group of distinct competitors, consumers and customers with distinct patterns of behaviour. You will quickly see that in a natural commercial region, everyone in your industry, including competitors, know each other.

USA.jpg

In Canada, most industries have four regional markets.

  • Quebec

  • Ontario

  • Western Canada

  • The Maritimes: much smaller than the other three, but also where competition is not as fierce.

 

In the United States, there are at least 8 regional markets. 

A business that ventures into the United States for the first time must tackle but one region. Whoever attempts to enter the American market without a regional strategy is bound to fail.

China maps.jpg

The Chinese market is also a collection of 7 regional markets.

In each of those markets, consumers not only have distinct patterns of behaviour, but speak different languages as well. The population of each region varies from 100 to 300 million! The neighbouring region of Hong Kong is as different from that of Shanghai as France is from Germany. Unless you are doing business online with Alibaba or JD.com, no distributor or partner can claim to cover more than a small fraction of the country.

 

How long do you have to work at penetrating a market before going on to the next one? The new markets generally take a minimum of 2 to 3 years to generate positive cash flows.

You therefore need a sound plan supported by management, adequate resources and the same perseverance as when the business was started in its first market. Do not attempt to enter into a new market with part-time resources and indulge in penny-pinching. You will kill your credibility. Play to win or simply pass.

bottom of page